The U.S. government has proposed both directly and indirectly to centralize control over U.S. Internet service providers. C|Net’s Declan McCullagh reports that an “Internet kill switch” proposal championed by by Sens. Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.) and Susan Collins (R-Maine) will be reintroduced in the new Congress very soon.
The idea is to give “kill switch” authority to the government for use in responding to some kind of “cyber-emergency.”
A government with “kill switch” power will use it when the “emergency” is a challenge to its authority as did Egypt’s Dictator Hosni Mubarak..
I believe to pass such legislation would be destructive to American commerce. It will never be used in good faith. Our current Democrat dictators would have a hey-day. Flipping an Internet “kill switch” would be stupid and self-destructive, tantamount to an auto-immune reaction that compounds the damage from a cyber-security incident.
Everyone recognizes that the more likely use of “kill switch” authority would be bad faith, as the Egyptian government illustrates, to suppress speech and assembly rights.
In the person of the Federal Communications Commission, the U.S. government has also proposed to bring Internet service providers under a regulatory umbrella that it could then use for censorship or protest suppression in the future.
On the TechLiberationFront blog, Larry Downes has recently completed a five-part analysis of the government’s regulatory plan. The intention of its proponents is in no way to give the government this kind of authority, but government power is not always used as intended, and there is plenty of scholarship to show that government agencies use their power to achieve goals that are non-statutory and even unconstitutional.
The D.C. area’s surfeit of recent weather caused the cancellation yesterday of a book event, discussing Evgeny Morozov’s The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom. Morozov argues that governments are ably using the Internet to stifle freedom movements.
Events going on here in the United States right now could position the U.S. government to exercise the kind of authority we might look down our noses at Egypt for practicing. The lesson from the Egypt story—what we know of it so far—is that eternal vigilance is the price of freedom.